DOG RACING: WHERE'S THE HARM?
by Paula Blanchard
When people go to a dog track, they see dogs chasing a lure, much
as they have seen their own dogs at home chase a cat or a squirrel. Dogs
love to run, they think; dogs love to chase. Where's the harm?
The public never gets to see the reality of a racing greyhound's
life. Offers are not made to give guided tours of breeding farms, and for
very good reason. The greyhound racing industry would like to promote the
image of healthy dogs frisking about a trainer, of people devoted to the
welfare of their animals, of a "sport" that simply allows animals
to do what they want to do naturally. The reality behind the image is cruel
and exploitive.
Here are some hard facts the racing industry doesn't want you to
know:
Overbreeding: Bred to be Dead
.....Greyhounds have large litters;
nine or ten puppies is not unusual. In the 12 years from 1989 to 2000 the
National Greyhound Association registered 77,852 litters, or (using a conservative
estimate of 6.5 puppies per litter) 507,596 greyhounds. Only a small percentage
of those puppies are likely to win any cash at the track. Experienced breeders
can identify the sure losers at a glance, and such puppies are the first
to be killed.
.....The rest begin training at six
months. They generally begin racing at 18 months of age, entering four
races to see if they are fast enough to race for money. Then the second
round of killing happens. Greyhound puppies or very young adults rarely
are rescued by adoption groups.
.....Greyhounds are litter registered
(tattooed) by three months of age and individually registered at 18 months.
Of the 507,596 born in 1989-2000, only 395,545 were individually registered.
That means that roughly 22 percent disappeared before they reached the
track.
Life at the Track
.....Breeding farms are located in every
state, and most of the legal owners of racing greyhounds do not see much
of their dogs. Some never see them at all. Usually an owner will lease
his dogs to a kennel operator, who will ship them to tracks all over the
country, moving them around among the 15 states that still allow live racing.
Greyhound racing is an interstate shell game: dogs that fail to win at
a top (Class A) track are moved to a lesser track and perhaps to a lesser
one after that, and so on until they fail to win at all, at which point
they are killed or adopted.
.....While racing at a particular track,
the dogs are kept in kennels at the track or nearby. They are confined
in crates stacked in tiers, each just large enough for a dog to stand or
lie down. Bedding generally consists of shredded newspapers or carpet scraps.
Rescued greyhounds often have open sores, the result of constant rubbing
against the wire mesh of their crates.
.....The dogs are taken out a few times
a day for training and to relieve themselves. Otherwise they are locked
in the crates for 20 hours or more a day. They wear rigid plastic or metal
muzzles whenever they are out of their crates. They race only once every
four days. Racing greyhounds are generally fed raw "4-D" meat
deemed unfit for human consumption, taken from animals that are diseased,
injured or dying between transit and slaughter.
Health
.....Because of the large numbers of
dogs confined in a small area and the constant turnover, parasite infestation
is inevitable. Greyhounds are often heavily infested with fleas, ticks
and internal parasites, especially tapeworms, hookworms and whipworms.
Many adopted greyhounds must be wormed repeatedly long after they have
left the track. Contagious diseases are also a constant risk as a result
of the large numbers of dogs kept in such close quarters. For example,
in 1999 a kennel cough and associated streptococcal toxic shock epidemic
caused a nationwide quarantine; nearly 100 greyhounds are known to have
died over the last decade due to sporadic outbreaks of these diseases.
Crowded conditions can lead to catastrophic accidents: in 1992 a kennel
fire killed 87 dogs in a private kennel compound located in Lynn, Massachusetts,
"home" to racers for Wonderland Greyhound Park. A repeat fire
in the same kennel in 1999 killed another 8.
.....Injuries on the track are common,
and veterinary care is often cursory, many times limited to the barest
first aid, since many of those dogs will not race again. The legs of many
retired greyhounds testify to hasty and careless setting of fractures at
the track. It is not unheard of for adoption kennels to receive dogs whose
fractures have been left untreated for weeks. However, these greyhounds
must be considered "lucky," since at least they were not killed
immediately. It is important to remember that the economics of dog racing
require that if a greyhound cannot "earn his keep" his place
in the kennel must be taken by another money-making racer. There is a constant
turnover.
.....Only a few states require tracks
to file injury reports that can be accessed through public records requests,
and because the formats of the reports vary it is difficult to compare
states. Here are some of the numbers for 2001, according to records obtained
by Greyhound Network News under public records requests:
.....In Texas, a total of 728 greyhounds
were injured at the state's three tracks during the 9 1/2-month racing
season of 2000-2001. Two dogs were euthanized at the track. Six more sustained
"catastrophic" injuries and were probably euthanized. In all,
278 dogs suffered major injuries, many of which were "career ending."
.....In West Virginia between October
2000 and May 2001, 664 dogs were injured at the state's two tracks. Of
these, 111 suffered bone fractures; four dogs were euthanized due to injuries,
three dogs suffered seizures and two dogs died following a race (cause
unlisted). The disposition of the severely injured dogs is unknown.
.....During the seven-month racing season
in Wisconsin, the following injuries were reported. (These include injuries
suffered at the state's three tracks, plus those recorded during training
and schooling races): Total injuries 322; serious injuries 84 (82 bone
fractures and two spinal injuries). The disposition of the seriously injured
dogs is unknown.
.....Because of their particular body
type (lack of body fat, thin coat and large muscle mass), greyhounds are
keenly sensitive to heat and cold. Racing in summer heat and humidity can
be especially dangerous, and heat stroke in racing greyhounds is a well-documented
occurrence. Heat stroke is a life-threatening emergency that often leads
to death without aggressive medical treatment. This treatment is often
not available or "cost effective" for stricken greyhounds.
"I had not thought death had undone so many." (Dante)
....The racing industry operates on
the assumption that most of the dogs it produces will be killed. Industry
representatives like to use the term "euthanized," but euthanasia
properly means the mercy-killing of an individual already dying and suffering
unbearable pain. Except when applied to injured dogs, "euthanasia"
in the racing world means something quite different: the deliberate killing
of healthy greyhounds -- many two years old or younger -- in order to maximize
profit.
.....No one knows exactly how many dogs
are put down by industry veterinarians because most states are not required
to keep disposition records. Some numbers are available. In Pittsfield,
Massachusetts, for example, more than 1,200 racing dogs were killed at
a local shelter from 1987 to 1992. Mainly the evidence is in the larger
numbers: about 20,000 greyhounds a year simply disappear. They are not
racing, they are not adopted; they are nowhere.
.....There have been discoveries of
whole kennels full of dogs left to starve to death as well as corpses of
greyhounds taken out into the desert and shot, their tattooed ears removed
to prevent identification. Hundreds of greyhounds are sold to laboratories
every year for medical experiments; they are considered desirable because
their gentle dispositions make them tractable under stress. Over three
years, the Colorado State University School of Veterinary Medicine killed
more than 2,600 greyhounds, using them for surgical demonstration. (Rocky
Mountain News) At the University of Illinois, greyhounds were poisoned
and clinicians stood by and watched as dogs suffered "marked hypothermia,
restlessness, panting, vomiting, signs of abdominal pain and seizures."
(National Library of Medicine)
.....The law requires that the legal
owner of a dog must consent before a dog is sold for medical experiments,
but since legal owners of greyhounds often have no contact with their dogs,
unscrupulous dealers have found it easy to circumvent the law. The incentive
to do so is compelling: A destroyed dog is worth nothing, but a dog sold
under the counter to a medical school is worth up to $500.
.....The traffic is by no means all
illegal. A number of greyhounds have been donated to universities over
the years. Institutions receiving them in recent years have included Arizona
State University, the University of Arizona, Mississippi State University,
Auburn (Alabama) University, and Kansas State University.
Adoption: The Good News, the Bad News
.....There are more than 150 privately
funded adoption organizations across the country. Run by volunteers and
funded by donations, they rescue and place 12,000-13,000 greyhounds a year.
Not only do they save greyhound lives, they create thousands of anti-racing
activists, for people who adopt one or two greyhounds turn into people
who want to save them all. Greyhounds are their own best advocates. Just
walking the streets of their own towns, these gentle, elegant dogs turn
heads and raise the pity and indignation of passers-by.
.....In 1987 the racing industry, in
an attempt to improve its public image, set up the American Greyhound Council.
The AGC finances a toll-free adoption inquiry number and provides stipends
to selected adoption programs. This gives the industry some cover and damage
control, since financing is only provided to groups that contractually
agree to promote a positive image of dog racing. So, in general, the adoption
movement is a two-edged sword, since it both promotes anti-racing sentiment
and provides the industry with a facade of seemingly benign and responsible
behavior. A list of nationwide adoption groups is available through GREYK
USA.
Tracks Leading Downhill
.....The racing industry's best year
was 1991, when fans bet a total of $3.4 billion on the dogs. Since then
there has been a precipitious decline. Sixteen tracks have either closed
or ended live racing, though three of those continue simulcasting (closed-circuit
TV broadcasts of races at other tracks).
.....State revenues from pari-mutuel
dog racing declined significantly from 1990-1998 (the latest figures available).
Some examples: Kansas, down 59%; Arizona, down 68%; Massachusetts, down
69%; Oregon, down 70%; Florida, down 71%; Connecticut, down 79%; New Hampshire,
down 84%. Seven states banned live and/or simulcast greyhound racing from
1993-2001. They are: Maine, Virginia, Vermont, Idaho, Washington, Nevada
and North Carolina. Only 15 states still allow live greyhound racing.
.....Based on recently published reports
(August 2001), the dog racing industry continues to decline dramatically.
According to gaming industry statistics, dog racing held only a 0.7% share
of the entire U.S. gambling market in 2000, a decline of 6.65% from 1999.
.....There are 46 surviving tracks in
the United States. Their owners are tenacious and politically powerful,
contributing large amounts of money to campaigns and holding the threat
of loss of state revenue and jobs over the heads of politicians. They will
keep on breeding, racing and killing greyhounds for some time yet. The
best weapon greyhound advocates have against them is education: telling
the truth about the reality of life -- and death -- at the track.
|